History

This Day in History — The Nuremberg Trials Begin

On this day in 1945

On November 20, 1945, an international tribunal opened in Nuremberg's Palace of Justice, putting 22 Nazi leaders on trial; 19 were later convicted.

The Off-Key Bard steps inside the Palace of Justice in Nuremberg, Germany, on a cold November morning in 1945. Just six months after the surrender of the Third Reich, the victorious Allied powers have assembled an extraordinary courtroom, complete with simultaneous-translation headphones, stacks of captured Nazi records, and a dock holding prominent figures of Hitler's regime. Rather than resorting to summary executions or leaving accountability to individual nations, judges and prosecutors from four Allied powers prepare to put aggressive war, war crimes and crimes against humanity on trial under international law.

"State authority and military rank are not shields against individual criminal accountability when leaders orchestrate war and mass atrocity."

On November 20, 1945, the International Military Tribunal opened its trial of the major Nazi war criminals in Nuremberg. The United States, Britain, the Soviet Union and France had created the tribunal under the London Agreement and its charter, signed on August 8, 1945, according to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. The trial ran until October 1, 1946, as the Memorium Nuremberg Trials museum records. It tried 22 leaders of Nazi Germany, and 19 were convicted. It rested on a principle that was new in its scale: leaders could be held personally responsible for crimes committed through the state.

Why a Trial

The decision to hold a trial was not obvious. The Truman Library's online collection shows the Allies planning for years. The Moscow Declaration of October 1943 called for suspected war criminals to be arrested and returned for trial, and at Yalta in February 1945 the Allied leaders agreed to prosecute Axis leaders after victory. In the spring of 1945 President Truman received planning memoranda from Samuel Rosenman and Justice Robert Jackson, and on May 2, 1945 the White House issued Executive Order 9547 and a statement by Truman. The USHMM notes that the United States had proposed a trial instead of summary execution. History.com says documenting the crimes in court was a key reason the Allies preferred trials.

The London Charter established three categories of offenses within the tribunal's jurisdiction: crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. The indictment filed on October 18, 1945, organized the prosecution into four counts: common plan or conspiracy, crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. The distinction matters because the fourth count did not represent an entirely separate category of atrocity. Instead, the conspiracy charge addressed participation in a common plan to commit the crimes alleged by the prosecution. The tribunal was examining both the actions of Nazi leaders and their responsibility for planning, directing, and carrying out those actions through the institutions of the state.

Nuremberg was chosen for symbolic reasons as well as practical ones. Deutschland.de says the city had hosted Nazi mass rallies and symbolized the regime's ideology, and that the Palace of Justice had an adjoining prison. The National WWII Museum describes the city as a base of Nazi power and says it was in ruins by 1945.

The Defendants

Twenty-four people were indicted, according to the USHMM. Gustav Krupp was excluded because of age and failing health, and Robert Ley died by suicide on the eve of the trial. Martin Bormann was tried in absentia. That left 22 on trial, of whom 21 appeared in court. The Jackson List by John Q. Barrett says Ernst Kaltenbrunner was ill when the trial opened, so on the first day of pleas only 20 defendants answered in court.

The State Department notes that Hitler was not indicted because he died by suicide in April 1945, and History.com says Heinrich Himmler and Joseph Goebbels also died by suicide in spring 1945. History.com adds that six Nazi organizations, including the Gestapo, were indicted too. Deutschland.de names Hermann Göring, Rudolf Hess, Joachim von Ribbentrop, Albert Speer and Wilhelm Keitel among the defendants at the opening.

The Trial

The trial opened on November 20 in Courtroom 600, where prosecutors read the long indictment. The Jackson List says defendants entered pleas the next day. Twenty pleaded not guilty, and no defendant was allowed to make a speech, a condition the Soviet Union had demanded because its chief prosecutor, Roman Rudenko, had not yet arrived.

Also on November 21, Jackson delivered the opening statement for the prosecution, which ran 61 typed pages and lasted into the late afternoon, according to the Jackson List. He called it "the first trial in history for crimes against the peace of the world," and said "5,700,000 Jews are missing." The USHMM quotes him describing wrongs "so calculated, so malignant and so devastating" that civilization could not tolerate their being ignored. He argued that individuals, including heads of state, could be prosecuted for international crimes, and that aggressive war was criminal in itself. Jackson called the tribunal "novel and experimental," Barrett notes.

The prosecution relied heavily on the Nazi regime's own surviving records. Allied investigators gathered thousands of official German documents, photographs, films, military orders, and administrative records to demonstrate how aggressive war, persecution, forced labor, and mass murder had been organized. The tribunal heard testimony and examined evidence over more than two hundred court days, producing a transcript running to thousands of pages. The proceedings also presented a formidable technical challenge: judges, prosecutors, defendants, and witnesses worked in English, French, German, and Russian. A simultaneous interpretation system allowed participants to follow testimony through headphones, making the trial an important early demonstration of large-scale multilingual courtroom proceedings. Rather than resting primarily on accusations from the victorious powers, prosecutors sought to establish the crimes through documents created by the regime itself.

The Verdicts

Hearings ended on September 1, 1946, and the verdict came on October 1, according to the USHMM. Nineteen defendants were convicted and three acquitted. Twelve were sentenced to death, which History.com says included one in absentia (Bormann). The National WWII Museum says three received life imprisonment, and four received terms of 10 to 20 years. Deutschland.de notes that Hess received life and Speer 20 years.

Ten were hanged on October 16, 1946. Göring died by suicide the night before, with a cyanide capsule that History.com says he had hidden in a jar of skin medication. The USHMM says Bormann was later found to have died in Berlin. The State Department's summary of the figures does not fully add up, which is why this post relies on the other sources for counts.

The Later Trials

Nuremberg did not end with the International Military Tribunal's verdict. Between 1946 and 1949, American military tribunals conducted twelve additional proceedings against doctors, judges, military officers, industrialists, SS officials, and other figures associated with Nazi crimes. These Subsequent Nuremberg Trials operated under Control Council Law No. 10 rather than the original four-power International Military Tribunal. Telford Taylor served as the chief American prosecutor. According to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, 185 defendants were indicted across the twelve proceedings, and 177 stood trial. Among the best-known cases were the Doctors Trial, which examined medical experiments and other atrocities, and the Judges Trial, which addressed the legal profession's participation in Nazi persecution. The last judgments and proceedings continued into 1949, demonstrating that accountability extended beyond the small group of leaders tried in the original courtroom.

Legacy and Criticism

History.com says most observers saw the trials as a step forward and says they influenced the 1948 UN Genocide Convention, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the 1949 Geneva Conventions, the 1961 Eichmann trial, and the tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. Deutschland.de says the UN codified the "Nuremberg Principles" in 1950. The National WWII Museum notes the indictment used the word "genocide," coined by Raphael Lemkin, but the USHMM says the verdict did not adopt the term.

The trials were controversial then and are now. History.com reports defense arguments that the charges applied retroactively and that the trial was "victor's justice," and that Chief Justice Harlan Stone called the proceedings a "sanctimonious fraud" and Justice William O. Douglas said the Allies "substituted power for principle." The National WWII Museum says open access to the evidence made it harder to dismiss the case. The USHMM adds limits of its own: the judges considered only wartime crimes against humanity and not prewar persecution, many perpetrators were never tried, and interest in prosecutions waned by the late 1950s.

Through ruined lands and shattered pride,
The courtroom doors were opened wide.
Not vengeance alone, but law took stand—
That grave crimes answer to command.

The trial did not end war crimes, and it was not a complete answer to the problem of international justice. What it showed is that the actions of national leaders could be examined in a court, with evidence, defense counsel and a verdict, and that a record built on the regime's own documents could outlast the argument. Eighty-one years later, Courtroom 600 is part of a memorial, and the principle that office and rank do not place anyone beyond accountability still shapes how the world confronts atrocity.

Sources