The Off-Key Bard
History

This Day in History — The Guns Fall Silent: The Armistice of 1918

On this day in 1918

At 11 a.m. on November 11, 1918, the Western Front fell silent, six hours after the signing and after about 10,900 casualties on the final day.

The Off-Key Bard stands somewhere along the Western Front in northern France. It is a cold November morning in 1918, and the landscape bears the scars of more than four years of industrial warfare. The earth has been torn apart by artillery. Trees stand shattered. Villages have been reduced to rubble, and miles of trenches cut through fields that once supported farms and families. Soldiers wait beneath the sound of the guns. They have been told that the fighting will stop at eleven o'clock. Until that moment arrives, the war continues.

"After four years of devastation, millions of deaths, and an entire generation changed forever, the guns are finally about to fall silent."

On November 11, 1918, at 11:00 a.m. Paris time, an armistice between Germany and the Allies took effect, ending the major fighting on the Western Front. It had been signed in the early hours of the morning in a railway carriage in the Forest of Compiègne. But it was an armistice, not a peace treaty. November 11 ended the shooting in the west. It did not settle the questions that had produced the war, and the consequences of those questions would shape the century.

The Road to the Railway Carriage

The war began in the summer of 1914 with the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo and a chain of alliance commitments that pulled much of Europe into it. On the Western Front it settled into trenches, shell craters and barbed wire. The Imperial War Museums record that on the first day of the Somme, July 1, 1916, British forces suffered 57,470 casualties, including 19,240 killed, the bloodiest day in British military history. The battle ran until November 18 and left over a million casualties on both sides.

Two events changed the balance in 1917: revolution in Russia and the entry of the United States into the war on April 6. Germany tried to win before American strength arrived, with a spring offensive in 1918 that failed. Then the Allies struck back. The Imperial War Museums date the start of the Hundred Days Offensive to Amiens on August 8, 1918, where 534 tanks led an attack that took the Germans by surprise, and about 30,000 German soldiers surrendered. Ludendorff called it the "black day of the German Army." The Allies broke through the strongest section of the Hindenburg Line at the St Quentin Canal on September 29. By the museum's count, Allied casualties from August to November were about 700,000, and German casualties were slightly higher, about 760,000.

Germany's partners fell away. According to History Ireland, Bulgaria's armistice took effect on September 29, the Ottoman Empire signed the Peace of Mudros on October 30, and Austria-Hungary signed the Villa Giusti armistice on November 3. On September 28, Ludendorff privately accepted that the war was lost and urged an armistice based on Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points.

Collapse at Home

Defeat at the front met revolution at home. Britannica says sailors mutinied at Kiel on October 29, the mutiny became open revolution by November 4, and workers' and soldiers' councils formed in industrial centers. On November 9, Prince Max of Baden announced on his own initiative that Kaiser Wilhelm II was abdicating. The Social Democrats had by then withdrawn their support from his government, Philipp Scheidemann proclaimed a republic, and Friedrich Ebert headed a provisional government. The Kaiser fled to the Netherlands on November 10 and signed his abdication on November 28.

Compiègne

The German delegation was led not by a general but by a civilian, Matthias Erzberger. Wikipedia lists Count Alfred von Oberndorff, Major General Detlof von Winterfeldt and Captain Ernst Vanselow with him. Marshal Ferdinand Foch, the Allied supreme commander, and Admiral Rosslyn Wemyss of Britain were among those on the Allied side. They met in Foch's private train, parked on a siding in the forest near Rethondes. The Germans were given the terms on November 8 and 72 hours to accept, according to the National WWI Museum.

When the Germans asked what the Allies proposed, Foch is quoted as saying, "I have no proposals to make," according to the UK National Archives and HISTORY. French General Maxime Weygand read the terms. Erzberger read a declaration pledging that Germany would do everything possible to carry them out, while warning that some terms were harsh enough to risk anarchy and famine. Three years later, HISTORY notes, he was murdered by German ultranationalist extremists.

What the Armistice Required

The text, published by the U.S. State Department's Office of the Historian, was severe. German forces had to leave Belgium, France, Luxembourg and Alsace-Lorraine within 15 days and evacuate the left bank of the Rhine. Allied and American garrisons would hold Mainz, Koblenz and Cologne, with bridgeheads of a 30-kilometer radius on the right bank, and a neutral zone would be set up beyond them. Germany had to surrender 5,000 guns, 25,000 machine guns, 3,000 trench mortars and 1,700 aircraft, along with 5,000 locomotives, 150,000 railway wagons and 5,000 motor lorries. Submarines were to be handed over, and six battle cruisers, ten battleships, eight light cruisers and fifty destroyers were to be disarmed and interned. Allied prisoners were to be repatriated without reciprocity. The blockade continued. Britannica adds that the Brest-Litovsk and Bucharest treaties were annulled. The armistice ran for 36 days with an option to extend.

Why Eleven O'Clock?

The official armistice document records that the agreement was signed at 5:00 a.m. French time on November 11, 1918. Contemporary British parliamentary records give the same time, although some later accounts describe the signing as occurring shortly afterward. What matters for the ceasefire is the agreed effective time: Article I required hostilities on land and in the air to stop six hours after the signing, and the armies were instructed to cease fighting at 11:00 a.m. Paris time.

That decision gave commanders time to communicate the ceasefire along a front extending hundreds of miles, where orders still had to reach units in trenches, artillery positions and forward areas. It also meant that the fighting would continue for hours after Germany had accepted the terms. The familiar phrase "the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month" describes the moment the armistice took effect, not the moment the agreement was signed.

The Last Six Hours

The delay had a cost. Wikipedia, citing Joseph Persico, gives 10,944 casualties on November 11, of which 2,738 men died, and AP cites Persico for about 10,900 killed, wounded and missing on all sides. Many Allied artillery units kept firing so they would not have to haul spare ammunition back, according to Wikipedia. Some American commanders continued attacking until 11 a.m. while others did not, HISTORY reports, and AP describes several reasons fighting continued: fear that the enemy would not honor the agreement, hatred after four years, commanders seeking a last victory, and poor communications. General John Pershing, who wanted to continue the fighting, later had to explain the heavy American losses to Congress.

Several soldiers killed during the final hours are remembered by name, although claims about who was absolutely last require caution. Henry Gunther of the American 313th Infantry Regiment, 79th Division, was killed at approximately 10:59 a.m. while advancing toward a German position. He is widely recognized as the last American soldier killed in the fighting. French soldier Augustin Trébuchon died shortly before the ceasefire while carrying a message, although accounts differ on the exact time and circumstances. Canadian soldier George Lawrence Price was killed near Mons at approximately 10:58 a.m. and is commonly identified as the last Canadian and Commonwealth soldier killed. British soldier George Edwin Ellison was also killed that morning near Mons, though accounts differ on the precise time. These individual stories capture the tragedy of the final hours, but incomplete records and continued isolated incidents make identifying the absolute last casualty of the war difficult.

The Silence

At eleven the fire largely stopped. The Courier in Australia reports that the silence appears to have been real, with a measurable drop in artillery and small-arms fire, citing recording tape from Allied range-finding units, although men were still killed in random clashes afterward. Robert Casey, an artilleryman in Battery C, 124th Field Artillery, 33rd Division, wrote, "We cannot comprehend the stillness," as quoted by the National WWI Museum. The Courier quotes Colonel Thomas Gowenlock saying there were no celebrations at the front.

Far from the front it was different. HISTORY shows footage of crowds in New York, Washington and Paris. For soldiers and civilians who had lived through the war, the news brought relief, and for many it also brought grief, exhaustion and uncertainty.

The Cost

Britannica gives its best estimates of the war's toll: some 8.5 million soldiers killed and died, and civilian deaths that "have been estimated" at around 13 million, with the warning that a completely accurate table may never be compiled. The United States lost 116,516 killed and died, per Britannica's table. The empires of Germany, Austria-Hungary, Russia and the Ottomans were gone or transformed.

From Armistice to Treaty

Britannica says the final peace treaty was presented to a German delegation on May 7, 1919, and signed on June 28, 1919, exactly five years after the Sarajevo assassination. It included the Covenant of the League of Nations, adopted on April 28, 1919, though the U.S. Senate declined to approve American membership in March 1920. Germany's army was capped at 100,000 men, the Rhineland was demilitarized, and a commission set reparations at $33 billion in 1921. Many Germans bitterly called it a "dictated" peace and a violation of the Fourteen Points. Britannica notes that many historians argue this resentment, combined with later lax enforcement, helped pave the way for German militarism in the 1930s. That is a contributing factor, not the whole story of how another world war began.

Remembering November 11

President Wilson issued the first proclamation marking the anniversary on November 11, 1919, according to HISTORY. Congress made November 11 a federal holiday on May 13, 1938. On June 1, 1954, President Eisenhower signed the law replacing "Armistice" with "Veterans" to honor those who served in World War II and the Korean War. The Uniform Monday Holiday Act of 1968 moved the holiday to a Monday, with the first Monday observance on October 25, 1971, but many states ignored the change. President Ford signed a law returning it to November 11 beginning in 1978.

Elsewhere the day is Remembrance Day. HISTORY says Canada, Britain, France and Australia commemorate on or near November 11, that Britain observes Remembrance Sunday on the second Sunday of November, and that many countries in Europe and the Commonwealth keep two minutes of silence at 11 a.m. The red poppy has its roots in John McCrae's poem "In Flanders Fields." Veterans Affairs Canada says he wrote it after his friend Lieutenant Alexis Helmer was killed on May 2, 1915, with wild poppies blooming between the grave markers where Helmer was buried, and it first appeared in Punch that December.

At eleven's chime, the cannons ceased,
And shattered fields were granted peace.
Yet silence held the names of those
Who never saw the war's close.

The armistice is remembered as a moment of relief, and it was. It is also a lesson in how slowly a decision becomes a fact on the ground. The agreement was signed around dawn, and thousands of men became casualties in the hours before it took effect, in a war whose outcome was already settled.

It also shows the difference between ending a war and making a peace. The guns stopped on the Western Front on November 11, but the political order that followed took months to build, and its flaws were still being argued over for decades. The soldiers who stood in the line at eleven o'clock could not know any of that. They knew only that the guns had stopped.

Sources

← Back to the Desk — History